Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Let yourself be heard in our official polls!

Should a Hardcore Ironman Mode player lose their status when dying at:?

A Player-Owned House in PvM Mode: lose status
39
12%
A Player-Owned House in PvM Mode: keep status
28
9%
Clan Wars in wilderness mode: lose status
30
9%
Clan Wars in wilderness mode: keep status
33
10%
Wearing a salve (e) amulet: lose status
39
12%
Wearing a salve (e) amulet: keep status
28
9%
Dying by not responding to a random event: lose status
16
5%
Dying by not responding to a random event: keep status
48
15%
Dying at Zulrah: lose status
34
10%
Dying at Zulrah: keep status
33
10%
 
Total votes: 328

User avatar
Slap a ho
Champion
Posts: 1673
Joined: Mon Nov 10, 2014 11:26 am

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Slap a ho » Fri Dec 21, 2018 5:31 pm

POH PVM - Lose
Clan Wars Wilderness mode - Lose
Salve (e) - Lose
Dying to a random - Keep
Dying at Zulrah - Lose

It needs to be consistent with OSRS to alleviate any confusion on what is and is not a safe death. Doing so, it’ll be very easy to redirect players to the official OSRS Wiki, as well as make it easy to add to ours.
Image

User avatar
Respire1337
Moderator
Posts: 1724
Joined: Fri Dec 02, 2016 9:56 pm

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Respire1337 » Fri Dec 21, 2018 7:43 pm

Slap a ho wrote:POH PVM - Lose
Clan Wars Wilderness mode - Lose
Salve (e) - Lose
Dying to a random - Keep
Dying at Zulrah - Lose

It needs to be consistent with OSRS to alleviate any confusion on what is and is not a safe death. Doing so, it’ll be very easy to redirect players to the official OSRS Wiki, as well as make it easy to add to ours.
I agree with some.
Are we allowing ring of life to save the player's HCIM status? If yes, then salve should have no effect on the player's status. ( if you die with a salve (e) anywhere, it won't retain the HCIM status).
Do randoms even kill you anymore? They just jail you ( at least from what I know ).
I agree with dying to Zulrah being "dangerous" , but at the moment, our safe death will make no sense for the new HCIM that are familiar with Zulrah being a safe death. So, what I suggest here is to change the Zulrah death mechanic to be a dangerous death, where you lose all of your unprotected stuff and you can reclaim everything back from the Priestess Zul-Gwenwynig for 100M gp ( salve(e) effect should be turned off in Zulrah's shrine to prevent from losing it by mistake).
Image

User avatar
Iron adam
Honor Player
Posts: 9611
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2014 6:07 am
Location: Monys
Contact:

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Iron adam » Fri Dec 21, 2018 7:47 pm

Respire1337 wrote:Are we allowing ring of life to save the player's HCIM status? If yes, then salve should have no effect on the player's status. ( if you die with a salve (e) anywhere, it won't retain the HCIM status).
Ring of life isn't saving the status because you aren't dying when it activates. It will only activate if you are below 10% health (1-9 hp). If you're dead, you're dead. Salve only activates when you are 0 hp dead dead dead.
If ring of life has activated, you wont lose the status because you haven't died.
I fucking love Thoby..

#OSRSPathing2020

User avatar
Respire1337
Moderator
Posts: 1724
Joined: Fri Dec 02, 2016 9:56 pm

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Respire1337 » Fri Dec 21, 2018 8:07 pm

Admin adam wrote:
Respire1337 wrote:Are we allowing ring of life to save the player's HCIM status? If yes, then salve should have no effect on the player's status. ( if you die with a salve (e) anywhere, it won't retain the HCIM status).
Ring of life isn't saving the status because you aren't dying when it activates. It will only activate if you are below 10% health (1-9 hp). If you're dead, you're dead. Salve only activates when you are 0 hp dead dead dead.
Oh yeah, I forgot how things work, bad moderator. Either way, salve(e)=does not save the HCIM status.
Image

User avatar
Slap a ho
Champion
Posts: 1673
Joined: Mon Nov 10, 2014 11:26 am

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Slap a ho » Fri Dec 21, 2018 9:43 pm

Respire1337 wrote:
Slap a ho wrote:POH PVM - Lose
Clan Wars Wilderness mode - Lose
Salve (e) - Lose
Dying to a random - Keep
Dying at Zulrah - Lose

It needs to be consistent with OSRS to alleviate any confusion on what is and is not a safe death. Doing so, it’ll be very easy to redirect players to the official OSRS Wiki, as well as make it easy to add to ours.
I agree with some.
Are we allowing ring of life to save the player's HCIM status? If yes, then salve should have no effect on the player's status. ( if you die with a salve (e) anywhere, it won't retain the HCIM status).
Do randoms even kill you anymore? They just jail you ( at least from what I know ).
I agree with dying to Zulrah being "dangerous" , but at the moment, our safe death will make no sense for the new HCIM that are familiar with Zulrah being a safe death. So, what I suggest here is to change the Zulrah death mechanic to be a dangerous death, where you lose all of your unprotected stuff and you can reclaim everything back from the Priestess Zul-Gwenwynig for 100M gp ( salve(e) effect should be turned off in Zulrah's shrine to prevent from losing it by mistake).
OSRS Zulrah isn’t a safe death. The only difference between OSRS death and PkH death at Zulrah is you don’t have to claim your items on PkH. It’s free to claim on OSRS. It’s safe in terms of your items not having the chance of being lost unless you die again before reclaiming. Statuses are different.

Randoms kill you which leads to jailing, at least it used to. Maybe this has changed, but I haven’t had a random in forever tbh. Literally 1+ year since a random event. Do they even work anymore?

Adam answered the RoL.
Image

User avatar
Iron adam
Honor Player
Posts: 9611
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2014 6:07 am
Location: Monys
Contact:

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Iron adam » Fri Dec 21, 2018 9:49 pm

Slap a ho wrote:Randoms kill you which leads to jailing, at least it used to. Maybe this has changed, but I haven’t had a random in forever tbh. Literally 1+ year since a random event. Do they even work anymore?
Randoms don't kill players anymore. They just get jailed.
I fucking love Thoby..

#OSRSPathing2020

User avatar
Respire1337
Moderator
Posts: 1724
Joined: Fri Dec 02, 2016 9:56 pm

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Respire1337 » Fri Dec 21, 2018 9:59 pm

Slap a ho wrote:
Respire1337 wrote:
Slap a ho wrote:POH PVM - Lose
Clan Wars Wilderness mode - Lose
Salve (e) - Lose
Dying to a random - Keep
Dying at Zulrah - Lose

It needs to be consistent with OSRS to alleviate any confusion on what is and is not a safe death. Doing so, it’ll be very easy to redirect players to the official OSRS Wiki, as well as make it easy to add to ours.
I agree with some.
Are we allowing ring of life to save the player's HCIM status? If yes, then salve should have no effect on the player's status. ( if you die with a salve (e) anywhere, it won't retain the HCIM status).
Do randoms even kill you anymore? They just jail you ( at least from what I know ).
I agree with dying to Zulrah being "dangerous" , but at the moment, our safe death will make no sense for the new HCIM that are familiar with Zulrah being a safe death. So, what I suggest here is to change the Zulrah death mechanic to be a dangerous death, where you lose all of your unprotected stuff and you can reclaim everything back from the Priestess Zul-Gwenwynig for 100M gp ( salve(e) effect should be turned off in Zulrah's shrine to prevent from losing it by mistake).
OSRS Zulrah isn’t a safe death. The only difference between OSRS death and PkH death at Zulrah is you don’t have to claim your items on PkH. It’s free to claim on OSRS. It’s safe in terms of your items not having the chance of being lost unless you die again before reclaiming. Statuses are different.

Randoms kill you which leads to jailing, at least it used to. Maybe this has changed, but I haven’t had a random in forever tbh. Literally 1+ year since a random event. Do they even work anymore?

Adam answered the RoL.
I wasn't referring at all to the OSRS Zulrah, but to ours. Either change the way the current death mechanic works at Zulrah to be a regular death, where you lose your stuff, or just have Zulrah be a safe death for HCIM too, as the PkHonor players are gonna be confused when they die at Zulrah and they get their HCIM status revoked, knowing that Zulrah is a safe death.
Image

User avatar
Slap a ho
Champion
Posts: 1673
Joined: Mon Nov 10, 2014 11:26 am

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Slap a ho » Fri Dec 21, 2018 11:19 pm

Respire1337 wrote:I wasn't referring at all to the OSRS Zulrah, but to ours. Either change the way the current death mechanic works at Zulrah to be a regular death, where you lose your stuff, or just have Zulrah be a safe death for HCIM too, as the PkHonor players are gonna be confused when they die at Zulrah and they get their HCIM status revoked, knowing that Zulrah is a safe death.
What I’m saying is both versions are 99% similar. PkH version isn’t really different than OSRS version. The only difference is you have to travel back to Zul-Andra to claim your stuff in OSRS. On PkH, the only difference is you DON’T have to travel back to Zul-Andra to claim your stuff. It’s more or less an inconvienence on OSRS than anything.
Image

User avatar
Jonas
Head Wiki Editor
Posts: 4903
Joined: Mon Aug 26, 2013 8:50 pm
Location: Lithuania.

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Jonas » Sat Dec 22, 2018 12:36 am

POH PVM - Lose
Clan Wars Wilderness mode - Lose
Salve (e) - Lose
Dying to a random - Keep
Dying at Zulrah - Lose

For Zulrah, I believe HCIM should lose their status if they die there and we should add a "second life" every 24 hours for the boss like OSRS has. That ability could be achieved for completing all achievements maybe?
Image

User avatar
Slap a ho
Champion
Posts: 1673
Joined: Mon Nov 10, 2014 11:26 am

Re: Hardcore Ironman Mode on death

Post by Slap a ho » Sat Dec 22, 2018 12:44 am

Jonas wrote:For Zulrah, I believe HCIM should lose their status if they die there and we should add a "second life" every 24 hours for the boss like OSRS has. That ability could be achieved for completing all achievements maybe?
That is only granted upon completing the elite Western Province Diary. Would be a really good incentive to begin making a diary for outside the wilderness...
Image

Post Reply